AP Lang - Slaughterhouse Five
Friday, August 3, 2012
Chapter 10 - Poo-tee-weet
Surrounded by death and heartache, Billy's final observation of the novel is the singing birds. "Poo-tee-weet." In some ways, I was bothered by Billy's (and Vonnegut's) ignorance to the surrounding deaths. It seemed like, throughout the novel, death was everywhere, but it was never sufficiently acknowledged. Derby, one of the only REAL characters in the book, had his trial and death explained in one sentence. So it goes. Despite my frustration with the ending of the novel, I do believe that Vonnegut had a bigger idea than just ignoring death. The birds chirping at the end of the story were a symbol of hope. Vonnegut is displaying to the reader that in times of struggle, there is always a glimmer of hope, a light at the end of a tunnel. Although nearly every noteworthy event in the novel was negative, the story ended on a positive note. Poo-tee-weet.
Chapter 10 - Elegy
The chapter begins with an introduction of deaths which occurred in the year 1968. I interpreted this as Vonnegut's unique style of elegy. However, rather than write extensively about the sadness of such tragic deaths as a normal elegiac would, Vonnegut simply shrugs off the deaths. "Robert Kennedy...died last night. So it goes.... Martin Luther King was shot a month ago. So it goes.... My father died many years ago now... So it goes." Although it seems to me like Vonnegut is paying respect to his heroes in some way, he does not allow himself to become caught up in the emotion side of the tragedies. Staying consistent with his "Serenity" outlook on life, Vonnegut views these deaths as pieces of a puzzle that ultimately defines the way of the universe.
Chapter 9 - The Serenity Prayer
Vonnegut discussed the Serenity Prayer earlier into the novel. He told the audience that Billy kept the prayer displayed conspicuously in his office for his patients to take refuge in the safety of its words. The prayer reemerges as an item of symbolism and deeper meaning. While Montana Wildhack is breastfeeding her infant, Billy catches a glimpse of the prayer displayed on a necklace in between her breasts. In the prayer, God is called upon the give the "serenity to accept the things I cannot change." Billy Pilgrim, due to his encounter with the Tralfamadorians and his time travel has come to believe that nothing can be changed. He accepts hardships with impeccable serenity. I do not know if his calmness is courageous and virtuous or if it is merely a self-defense mechanism that he has created to protect himself from the inevitable sadness of life.
Chapter 9 - Situational Irony
On her way to the hospital to visit Billy after the plane crash, Valencia gets into a car wreck and dies in front of the hospital due to carbon monoxide poisoning. Vonnegut uses this clear situational irony to once again drive home the idea that bad things are destined to happen, and nobody (except Billy Pilgrim) can foresee their occurrence. Valencia was on the way to the hospital in a hysteria because of Billy's unfortunate plane crash, and she did not even consider that she herself would be in danger. Perhaps the greater irony in the situation, although somewhat predictable, was Billy's reaction to the death of his wife. Because he didn't mourn her death, people assumed that he was in a vegetable state with limited brain function. However, Billy was "preparing letters and lectures about the flying saucers, the negligibility of death, and the true nature of time." To me, it almost seems like Billy had seen his wife's unfortunate death many times during his travels and was waiting until that moment to intentionally become a crazy old man.
Thursday, August 2, 2012
Chapter 8 - PTSD
Billy, in the midst of celebration, is visible shaken by the Febs barbershop quartet. He flees to his room to avoid contact with people, and thinks back to the day that Dresden was bombed. For the first time in the novel, he allows himself to acknowledge the fact that part of himself was changed on the day of the bombing. I am extremely interested in psychology, and I have read numerous articles about Posttraumatic Stress Disorder, which was known as battle fatigue during World War II. Based on the articles that I have read, many soldiers return home with a very different demeanor and life outlook than they had when they left. Modern psychology allows veterans to return to their old selves over time; however, it is doubtful that such help was available for Billy. As a result, he lives a shallow life that is full of scars so deep that even he doesn't notice them.
Chapter 8 - Dynamic Character
Slaughterhouse-Five is full of people and names; however, none of these people contribute much to the overall action and plot of the story. Vonnegut admits this fact when he says, "There are almost no characters in this story, and almost no dramatic confrontations, because most of the people in it are so sick and so much listless playthings of enormous forces." Here is is expressing his idea that behind each character is a larger, more responsible force. Despite Vonnegut's belief, he does not deny the fact that Derby's finest moment was his singular act of courage and defiance. When nobody else would stand up for what is right, Vonnegut orchestrated Derby, the most unlikely of characters, to be the defiant and dynamic hero. In a story full of flat, static characters, Derby proves himself to be a model worthy of emulation. A lonesome dynamic character among "listless playthings." A man among boys.
Chapter 7 - Time Travel
Billy has made countless trips in and out of time throughout the novel. At the beginning of the story, I thought that the time travel was a figment of Billy's imagination, a result of Post Traumatic Stress brought on by the war. However, over the course of the novel, I have grown to believe that the Tralfamadorians really did teach Billy something about space and time that the normal human cannot understand. No normal human being would be able to predict and foresee his own death. This leaves me wondering if Billy really DID see those things before they happened, or if he merely convinced himself that he did in order to align his own beliefs with the Tralfamadorians. Space travel brings up many paradoxes, such as the Grandfather Paradox, where the traveler goes back in time and kills his grandfather before he produces offspring, thus making the travelers very existence and murder impossible. However, Billy does not seem to encounter any of these paradoxes.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)